The FTSE 100 may have ended the year only 5.5% down from its starting point, but it was an excitingly roundabout trip. Gilts offered a more comfortable and rewarding journey.
The FTSE 100 ended 2011 in negative territory after two years of rises following the traumas of 2008. It could have been much worse – in early October the FTSE was over 600 points lower than its eventual closing level of 5572.3. But then again it was nearly 600 points higher in early July before the latest round of euro troubles got under way.
The FTSE, with its increasingly foreign mix, is only part of the story, even though it represents 81% of UK market capitalisation.
Index 2011 Change Comment
FTSE 100 -5.5% The big caps headline number
FTSE 250 12.6% Mid-caps underperformed the big caps
FTSE Small Cap -14.9% Small caps lost out to the big caps and mid-caps
FTSE 350 High Yield +0.7% Value-investing had a better year than last
FTSE 350 Low Yield -14.2% Growth-investing was the wrong style for 2011
FTSE All-Share -6.7% Underperformed Footsie due to mid/small caps
FTSE Tobacco -23.9% A win for sin (and Neil Woodford – fund manager)!
FTSE Industrial Metals and Mining -52.6% Iron ore gets rusty
Over the year the dividend yield on the FTSE All-Share rose from 2.89% to 3.52%, partly due to the fall in values. Total dividend income from the UK equity market was up 13% from 2010. The return to dividend payments for BP, albeit at half their previous level, was an obvious contributor to this solid performance. It is a reminder that, for all the gloom, companies are still generating and paying out large amounts of real cash. Indeed, if you add back in the income over the year, the total return on the FTSE All-Share was only about 3% the wrong side of break even.
The overall drop in the UK equity market paralleled performance in most other stock markets. For example, the Euro Stoxx 50 fell by 17.1% amidst the euro troubles and the Nikkei 225 dropped by 17.3%. Emerging markets were also weak, with the FTSE All Emerging All-Cap down by 22.1% in US $ terms (21.5% in sterling terms). The best performer among major stock markets was the USA, where the S&P 500 moved from 1257.64 at the start of the year to 1257.60 at the end, albeit with more than a few exciting swings en route. So much for the loss of an AAA rating!
The place to be in 2011 was not equities, but government bonds. The benchmark ten year gilt yield started 2011 at 3.40% and ended it at just 1.98%, while the real yield on the FTSE Over 15 year Index-linked yardstick shrunk from 0.56% to -0.16% (i.e. negative real returns). The FTSE 10-15 year gilt index climbed by 15.1% in 2011 while the FTSE Over 15 years Index-linked index rose by 24.6%. It was a similar story around the world, with the obvious exception of the Eurozone problem countries. For example, the US 10 year+ Treasury bonds returned an impressive 26.5%.
COMMENT A year of poor equity performance and strong bond performance will have been bad news for defined benefit pension schemes. With 10 year gilt yields now little more than half UK equity yields, these are challenging times for all types of pension arrangement.

